Main menu


Inisherin Banshees: even better if you know the Irish history behind it

featured image

You don’t need a PhD in Irish history to know that – thank goodness, because I don’t have it – Inisherin’s Demiurges It’s not just a delightfully crazy tale of Irish madness. IT is is since writer and director Martin McDonagh ( in Bruges and Three Billboards Outside Ebbing, Missouri) is incapable of producing a boring story. But there’s more to it than appears on the surface.

Inisherin’s Demiurges It plays out like a very funny fairy tale or folktale, the story of two lifelong friends, Pádraic (Colin Farrell) and Colm (Brendan Gleeson). The two men live on a remote island off the coast of Ireland, sparsely populated by a group of eccentrics who have known each other forever and are unlikely to ever part. The only person with a desire to get off the island is Pádraic’s sister, Siobhán (Kerry Condon), who is sick and tired of everyone, especially men who, as she says, are “too boring.”

May be not all boring. One day, at their usual afternoon bar, Pádraic discovers that Colm is no longer his friend. The reason for the break is difficult for Pádraic to understand and even a little difficult for Colm, who can no longer deal with his friend. But when Pádraic can’t accept Colm’s decision, Colm sets out to make his intentions as clear as possible.

A man is sitting in a room;  others enter through the window.

Gleeson and Farrell The Demiurges of Inisherin.
Projector Pictures

McDonagh (Irish, but raised in London) is a playwright at heart and by profession, and he thrives on this kind of setup: a tightly controlled world of weirdos, a hothouse for fights and jokes, inside jokes and petty cattle and grudges that lasted so long. . people barely remember where they started. It provides extremely entertaining storytelling and does its best in this distinctively Irish setting. Their awkward couple pairings reunite Gleeson and Farrell as they turn into a Gothic crime comedy. in Bruges very memorable, it was the right choice. He’s great at his roles, Gleeson as a world-weary grump and Farrell as a gullible who seems to be missing a few screws.

But if you don’t detect what’s going on in the background Inisherin’s Demiurges, then plays out like a weird tale told over a few pints late at night. The movie really expands when you look at the background.

Because explosions are seen on the beach just across the road, on the opposite side of Inisherin. The characters occasionally comment on them, thinking about the fight that took place there, a conflict they hoped and believed would soon be over. It doesn’t matter – here on the island where Colm and Pádraic’s break catches everyone’s attention, it doesn’t touch them.

This fight is probably actually part of the Irish civil war. The film takes place in 1923, when this conflict has been going on for almost a year. Part of Ireland’s long history of strife and violence, it mostly has to do with very different views on British rule of the island. The civil war began after the Irish War of Independence and led to the establishment of Ireland as a free state that would nevertheless remain part of the Commonwealth of Nations (in other words, more like Canada than Scotland). Some who fought for independence with the Irish Republican Army supported the treaty that created the Free State; others vehemently opposed this, believing that Ireland should be completely free from British interference.

The result was a bloody war that lasted from June 1922 to May 1923, in which men fighting on the same side now fought each other. Inisherin’s Demiurges With that in mind and you can start to see what McDonagh is up to. The breakup between Colm and Pádraic works on its own terms, but it’s also a surprisingly violent fight between men who are basically brothers, a fight that has some logic but is still heartbreaking precisely because of the depth of history between them. It is conflict in the microcosm.

Two men look into the water away from the camera.  One looks at the other.

Gleeson and Farrell looking at the water The Demiurges of Inisherin.
Projector Pictures

The “banshees” of the title (and the song composed entirely by Colm) are also important. They come from Irish folklore: female spirits that scream, wail and mourn indicate that a family member will die soon. Inside Inisherin’s Demiurges, there is literally no death-death, but it is clear that this is the role played in the village by Mrs McCormick, the old pipe-smoker Pádraic avoids like the plague. Their dark premonitions suggest that death is on the horizon – literally, on the horizon they can see.

In the end, the characters think the conflict has waned along the way, and it looks like the conflict in Inisherin may be at its darkest, too. But this dialogue is meant to take on a bitter irony, or perhaps comedy’s darkest note, that in Ireland they are two sides of the same coin. Because we know that 100 years later, the conflict in Ireland has not subsided, even if an indefinite peace is achieved in the Republic. Much more conflict would arise, most of it in Northern Ireland (now part of the UK), especially during the Troubles from the 1960s to the 1990s. Much more blood would have been spilled and the conflicts would have divided Irish society for generations.

Which provides Inisherin’s Demiurges – undoubtedly a comedy and often hilarious – with its tragic spine. Friend against friend, brother against brother, lost love and grudges that tear apart the fabric of society; all in this little fairy tale. And the banshee stands in the foreboding background, screaming and mourning everything.

Inisherin’s Demiurges In theaters on October 21.